…as Adv Mokoko remains locked out of office
…after Court of Appeal ordered her reinstatement as Commissioner-General
…senior RSL insiders condemn apex court judgment as “impractical”
Mohloai Mpesi
A STANDOFF has erupted at Revenue Services Lesotho (RSL) after the Court of Appeal ordered the reinstatement of dismissed Commissioner-General, Advocate ’Mathabo Mokoko, leaving the institution facing a potentially difficult legal and administrative conundrum.
The apex court last Friday upheld Adv Mokoko’s appeal with costs, restoring a Labour Court judgment that found the RSL Board of Directors in contempt of court for dismissing her despite an interim order barring it from doing so.
The court ruling requires the board to reinstate Adv Mokoko or face 30 days in prison, a sentence imposed by the Labour Court but suspended on condition that the board complied with the reinstatement order.
The apex court judgment has opened a fresh dispute over its implementation, with some RSL insiders arguing that reinstatement is no longer possible because Adv Mokoko’s three-year contract expired on 31 August 2026. The term of the board that dismissed her also ended on 6 November 2026.
The insiders maintain that these developments have rendered the reinstatement dispute moot, while Adv Mokoko insists that the board remains bound by the court order and must comply with it regardless of the expiry of its members’ terms.
The dispute now puts RSL in a difficult position, with the former commissioner-general maintaining that the board members face imprisonment for their defiance of the courts, while those close to the institution question how an expired employment contract can be reinstated.
Background
Adv Mokoko, the first woman to head RSL, was appointed Commissioner-General on 1 September 2023, succeeding Mr Thabo Khasipe, who had left to become Executive Secretary of the Southern African Customs Union (SACU).
Her appointment was for three years, with an option of renewal for a further three years.
An admitted Advocate of the High Court and Court of Appeal, she had previously served as RSL Commissioner for Client Services and acted as Commissioner-General for more than eight months before her confirmation.
Her troubles began on 4 November 2025 when the board, chaired by Advocate Lindiwe Sephomolo KC, issued her with a show-cause letter demanding an explanation for why she should not be dismissed for alleged incompetence.
Rather than respond directly to the board, Adv Mokoko approached the Labour Court on 6 November 2025 challenging the threatened dismissal on various grounds.
Among other things, Adv Mokoko argued that she could not be dismissed without a formal disciplinary process. She also sought an interdict stopping the threatened dismissal.
Labour Court President Teboho Thoso granted an interim order restraining the board from terminating her employment pending the determination of her main application against the dismissal.
The order stated: “That the respondents be restrained and interdicted from dismissing, threatening to dismiss and/or acting on the letter annexure ‘MM2’ pending the outcome of this application.
“…The respondents may not dismiss the applicant without following the due process of a disciplinary hearing required by the contract of employment in terms of clauses 12 and 13 (c).”
Despite the interim order, the board proceeded to terminate her contract on 7 November 2025, citing her alleged failure to make representations in response to the show-cause letter. It subsequently appointed Commissioner for Client Services, Rakokoana Makoa, as Acting Commissioner-General.
On 17 December 2025, President Thoso found the entire board in contempt of court and sentenced its members to 30 days in prison. The sentence was suspended on condition that they reinstated Adv Mokoko.
The board appealed, and on 11 June 2026, Justice Fumane Khabo of the Labour Appeal Court overturned the contempt ruling.
Adv Mokoko subsequently approached the Court of Appeal, arguing that Justice Khabo had misdirected herself in overturning the Labour Court judgment.
The Court of Appeal, through its President, Justice Kananelo Mosito, upheld her appeal last Friday, restoring the contempt ruling and its accompanying sanction. Justice Mosito indicated that the full judgment would be made available later.
“It is ordered that the appeal is upheld with costs, and the judgment of the Labour Court is reinstated,” Justice Mosito said.
Litany of accusations
The board’s decision to dismiss Adv Mokoko followed a series of allegations concerning her conduct and performance as Commissioner-General.
Among other things, it accused her of failing to act in good faith by bypassing established governance structures and engaging external authorities on operational matters without the necessary authority.
She was also accused of “bypassing” the Financial and Audit Committee and the Board and writing to the Auditor-General, threatening a judicial review of her audit opinion of the RSL, “thereby failing to respect the authority and oversight of the Board”.
The Auditor General had issued a qualified opinion on the RSL.
The board further accused her of operational incompetence, citing escalating unresolved tax refund claims and an alleged failure to manage reputational risks facing the institution.
The termination letter, issued on 7 November 2025, largely mirrored the allegations contained in the show-cause letter.
Mokoko denies allegations
In her Labour Court papers, Adv Mokoko strongly denied the allegations, particularly claims that she had bypassed the board when she lodged a grievance against the Minister of Finance and Development Planning, Dr Retšelisitsoe Matlanyane. Adv Mokoko had accused the finance minister of interfering with her lawful duties.
She also disputed claims that she had failed to keep the board informed in accordance with established governance and accountability protocols.
Adv Mokoko had earlier told the National Assembly’s Portfolio Committee on the Economic Cluster that, in early September 2025, Dr Matlanyane had, in no uncertain terms, demanded the names of taxpayers, timelines for the payment of tax refund claims and reports on tax clearances issued.
She further alleged that the minister had demanded that she adjust the mining sector’s debt-to-equity ratio from 3:1 to 8:1.
Adv Mokoko said she had repeatedly sought the board’s intervention over what she considered ministerial interference in RSL’s operations.
She also denied writing to the Auditor-General or threatening judicial review.
Mokoko wants compliance
In an interview with the Lesotho Times this week, Adv Mokoko said she was prepared to give the RSL time to consider how it intended to comply with the Court of Appeal ruling.
“As an emerging professional executive leadership coach, I have learned and appreciate the importance and power of silence and waiting. So, there is no need to rush and fill the silence.
“Thus, it is important to give the RSL as an institution an opportunity to carefully decide how they want to comply with the Court Order of the Court of Appeal.
“The presiding (appeal) judge pointed out the fundamentals pursuant to why compliance to court orders for the rule of law and stability of society is critical. The learned judge indicated amongst others that compliance to court orders is essential for peace and order of societies. That if orders are not obeyed chaos may prevail.
“The deliberate noncompliance with court orders is a serious issue. I believe we all want peace and order and a country where rule of law prevails. I am therefore trusting God for the next steps,” Adv Mokoko said.
Contract expiry dispute
However, RSL insiders argue that the court ruling cannot practically be implemented because Adv Mokoko’s contract expired on 31 August 2026, more than two months before the Court of Appeal delivered its judgment.
One top insider, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said the reinstatement dispute had effectively been overtaken by events.
“On reinstatement, Adv Mokoko’s contract ended in August. Who will she be reinstated as, because her contract has ended?
“The contract has ended. It was a three-year contract. What if someone was already in office? She was not going to be able to get in. The arguments that were raised in the courts of law were moot because her contract ended,” the source said.
The source argued that Adv Mokoko’s appeal was principally aimed at securing a contempt conviction against the board, but that the expiry of her contract had changed the circumstances under which the reinstatement order would have to be implemented.
“What she filed at the Court of Appeal was to have the RSL Board of Directors convicted. If it (the Court of Appeal judgment) reinstates the Labour Court ruling, it has been overtaken by events because her contract has ended,” the source said.
The source also pointed out that the board members targeted by the contempt proceedings had themselves left office following the expiry of the board’s term on 6 November 2026.
“Those people that she says must be arrested (the Board of Directors), their term has also ended. The term of the board that was dealing with Adv Mokoko’s issues has ended.
“There is no way she can be reinstated. So, the matter goes back to the Labour Court to argue the case where she was fighting with the minister.
“One can only be compensated instead of being reinstated when their contract has ended,” the source said.
The source said the appointment of a new Commissioner-General would have to follow the relevant procedures, adding that the minister remained in office and some former board members could potentially return.
The source further revealed that a new board was still being constituted, with its membership yet to be made public.
Mokoko rejects moot argument
Adv Mokoko, however, dismissed the argument that the expiry of her contract had rendered the court proceedings moot, saying the issue had been brought to the court’s attention before judgment was delivered.
She said the Court of Appeal had proceeded with the matter despite being aware that her contract was due to expire.
“That’s not what the court said. The court order talks about reinstating me or that they should go to jail. You will understand that the finer detail is what they will do. That was discussed in court. I am the one who told the court when my contract would end, despite knowing that the court decided that justice will only be served if they do that (hear the case).
“My contract had about 10 months to run when they started doing that (hearing the case). So, whether the contract has ended or not, it is neither here nor there. The important thing is whether they are going to comply.”
She argued that the case was not simply an employment dispute but involved contempt of court and criminal liability arising from the board’s deliberate defiance of a judicial order.
“It is not simply like ordering Adv Mokoko to return to work, and then they would say the contract has ended,” she said.
She further maintained that the expiry of the board’s term did not absolve the institution or its former directors of their obligations under the law.
“The sanction they have right now is that they are convicted. It depends on how they want to serve that sentence. They are not different from men and women in prison. It would be a different matter if it were a civil matter … but it is not, because of the criminality of the act they committed.
“Two things: the order is not only for them, but also for the institution. The RSL still has to comply with the order. The proceedings talked about board members on a personal level, but also about the institution itself. The institution has always been a party to the proceedings.
“In any case, even if their contracts end, a contract can always be renewed. But also, there is a governing body; there is no vacuum. Somebody must be responsible for the actions of the institution,” she said.
Contacted for comment, Adv Sephomolo said she was no longer part of the RSL board and therefore could not respond to any matters related to RSL and its governance.
Dr Matlanyane’s phone was unreachable both via calls and WhatsApp.
