Lesotho Times
[adrotate banner="13"]
Local NewsNews

Uproar over PSs’ contract renewals

…as MPs question legality of extensions under Tenth Amendment

…Motšoane defends move but promises to return with ‘clear answer’

Mohloai Mpesi

THE renewal of contracts for eight principal secretaries (PSs) has sparked a heated debate in Parliament, with opposition MPs questioning the legality of the extensions and arguing that the Tenth Amendment to the Constitution Act, 2025, abolished the office of Principal Secretary.

The MPs contend that the extensions were unlawful because the Tenth Amendment introduced the position of Permanent Secretary and provided for existing PSs either to retire or continue serving under the new constitutional framework by undergoing a transparent recruitment process.

The issue was raised by the leader of HOPE-Mphatlalatsane, ’Machabana Lemphane-Letsie, who recently filed a question in the National Assembly seeking to establish how many PSs’ contracts had expired since the enactment of the Tenth Amendment. She also wanted to know how many contracts had been extended, for how long and under which legal framework.

The Tenth Amendment was gazetted on 13 August 2025 as the first set of constitutional reforms to emerge from the national reforms process. Among other things, it re-designates principal secretaries as permanent secretaries, places them under the Government Secretary and empowers the Public Service Commission (PSC) to appoint them.

The Act has since been challenged in court by, among others, the Law Society of Lesotho and activist Kananelo Boloetse, who argue that it was passed without following mandatory constitutional procedures.

Ms Lemphane-Letsie’s argument is that the Tenth Amendment changes the office of Principal Secretary to that of Permanent Secretary, and that under the new law a person who held the office of Principal Secretary may either retire or continue to serve in terms of the new procedures. The new procedures require a stringent recruitment process.

This is provided for in Section 163 (2) of the Tenth Amendment, which states: “Any person who under this Constitution or any existing law would have been required to vacate his or her office at the expiration of any period shall, within a period of six months of the coming into operation of this Constitution, vacate his or her office and may choose either (a) to retire from the office; or (b) continue to serve in the office subject to appointments, mechanisms and other procedure provided in this Constitution and any other legislation.”

Section 97 (3) (a), as amended, states: “A Permanent Secretary shall be appointed by the Public Service Commission through a transparent, merit-based, fair and competitive process as may be provided for in an Act of Parliament.”

Ironically, the government appears to have applied the new constitutional dispensation selectively, having appointed Mpopo Tšoele in terms of the Tenth Amendment as “permanent secretary” in  the Ministry of Local Government, Chieftainship, Home Affairs and Police in January 2026 and not as “principal secretary”.

In his response, the Minister of Public Service, Moeketsi Motšoane, told Parliament that the contracts of 12 PSs had expired after the Tenth Amendment came into force.

He said these were the PS in the Prime Minister’s Office (Thabo Moleko), the ministries of Labour and Employment (Moshe Mosaase), Law and Justice (Relebohile Lebeta), Public Service, Foreign Affairs and International Relations (Thabang Lekhela), Local Government and Chieftainship (’Mabataung Khalane), Education and Training (Ratšiu Majara) , Information, Communications, Science, Technology and Innovation (Kanono Ramashamole), Security Services (Mpho Marathane), Natural Resources (Lira Ralebese), Environment and Forestry (Maphakamile Xingwana) and Health (Matsoanelo Monyobi).

“Only eight PSs’ contracts have been renewed. The contract for the Office of the Prime Minister was extended for three months, from 17 January to 16 April 2026,” Mr Motšoane explained.

“Also, the contract of the PS for Labour and Employment was extended for three months, from 17 January to 17 April 2026. The contracts of the PSs for the ministries of Public Service, Foreign Affairs and International Relations (Mr Lekhela), Local Government and Chieftainship (Ms Khalane), Education and Training (Mr Majara), Information, Communications, Science, Technology and Innovation (Mr Ramashamole), and Natural Resources (Mr Ralebese) were extended until those positions are filled (with new PSs),” Mr Motšoane said.

He said the extensions were made in terms of Section 139 (1) and (2) of the Constitution of Lesotho, 1993, because their appointments had originally been made in terms of that law and the terms of their employment had not been changed.

Section 139 (1) states: “The power to appoint a person to hold or act in any office to which this section applies shall vest in the Prime Minister, acting after consultation with the Public Service Commission.

“Provided that the power to appoint a person to hold or act in any office upon transfer from another such office carrying the same emoluments shall vest in the Prime Minister.”

Section 139 (2) states that “the offices to which this section applies are the office of any Principal Secretary and the office of the Government Secretary”.

Ms Lemphane-Letsie then asked a supplementary question, requesting Mr Motšoane to explain how a contract for a position abolished by the Tenth Amendment could be extended in terms of an old provision.

She pointed out that the minister had relied on Section 139 (1) and (2) of the “old” Constitution, yet the contracts were extended after the enactment of the Tenth Amendment, which ended the position of Principal Secretary and introduced that of Permanent Secretary.

“I wish to ask the minister whether he is saying he extended contracts for positions that have been legally ended. Can it happen in law that a position ended by the Constitution has its contract extended? What do we call that…..?” Ms Lemphane-Letsie asked.

Mr Motšoane replied that the PSs were employed under the original Constitution and that nothing had changed.

“The section that I mentioned, Section 139, is clear that the contracts of PSs who were hired under the previous law, as I said, do not change. The conditions under which they were hired  (interjection)…” he said.

Before he could finish, Ms Lemphane-Letsie rose on a point of order, and insisted that the Tenth Amendment had ended the position of Principal Secretary and introduced that of Permanent Secretary.

“The 10th Amendment to the Constitution Act, which came into operation in August 2025, ended Principal Secretaries and introduced Permanent Secretaries,” she said.

She said the Amendment was clear that people whose positions were no longer provided for in law had to either retire or be hired in accordance with the new law.

“I am asking the minister which position the extension is for, because the law stated that after six months, people whose positions are no longer in the law have two options: to retire from the position or to be hired according to the new law.

“So, the question is, how were they given extensions when the new law prescribes a new methodology on how they should be hired …..?” she further asked.

Mr Motšoane  acknowledged that “the law does not work backwards, but forward”. He nonetheless appeared to have fumbled in his attempts to give a clear answer.

“Here we applied the law to people who were already in such positions. The Tenth Amendment talks about the appointment of PSs, not extensions or anything else,” he said.

Ms Lemphane-Letsie again rose on a point of order, challenging Mr Motšoane to quote the law that talks about the PSs.

“I wish the minister would quote the law where it talks about Principal Secretaries, because I quoted the transition clause, which says a person who holds a position that no longer exists in this law has, after six months, two options: to retire from the position or to continue under the conditions of the new law.

“So, he should explain which clause of the law he used to extend the contracts of these PSs, because the contracts are indefinite. They do not state when the extensions started and until when,” she said.

Mr Motšoane said Parliament was yet to enact the enabling legislation to give effect to the provision of the Tenth Amendment on the appointment of permanent secretaries.  

Ms Lemphane-Letsie countered saying that was not a good enough reason for  flouting the Tenth  Amendment to the Constitution.

“It would be unfortunate if you were to let the minister lie to the House and to the nation. I believe that he must read the clause. On appointment, it says it ‘may’ follow an Act of Parliament, not that it ‘should’ or ‘shall’.

“Here, we are not talking about appointments; we are talking about the extension of the contracts. The law is clear on what should happen after six months. How did the extension come about, and under which clause of this law? He must not mislead this House. He must read the clauses on extension, not appointment,” she said.

Mr Motšoane replied that the Tenth Amendment was not clear on whether it amended Section 139 of the original Constitution, and that it was also silent on extensions.

“I said the Tenth Amendment cannot work backwards. The people we are talking about were employed on the basis of the provisions of the law as it then stood.

“Maybe an amendment has been made to it, but the Tenth Amendment is not clear about amending Section 139. However, these PSs were hired under the provisions of that law before the Tenth Amendment came into operation.

“The Tenth Amendment is also silent on extensions. Therefore, there will never be a time I will stand here and talk about extensions,” he said.

Democratic Congress (DC) Proportional Representation (PR) legislator, Hlalele Letšaba, also rose on a point of order, arguing that Mr Motšoane’s response was based on Section 139, which has since been repealed by the Tenth Amendment.

“The minister is answering based on Section 139 of the Constitution. Section 139 talks about the Principal Secretary and the Government Secretary, whereas the Tenth Amendment has been passed and repealed Section 139. We are now talking about Permanent Secretaries.

“This House will be contradicting itself if we discuss a law that it has repealed and replaced with a new one…Things must be done in terms of the new law….” he said.

Mr Motšoane then appeared to go off tangent again by suggesting  that the Tenth Amendment did not change the position of Principal Secretary to that of Permanent Secretary. He undertook to consult further and return to the House with a clear answer.

“When the Tenth Amendment came, it did not change Principal Secretaries to Permanent Secretaries. It left them as Principal Secretaries. What the law sought was that, from the point where the Tenth Amendment starts, we will have people appointed as Permanent Secretaries. It did not change the Principal Secretaries to Permanent….. These people were hired under the provisions of the law (old law).

“The question is, what would the PS be called after six months when the Tenth Amendment came into operation? But since I am not a legal practitioner, I should go back and consult,” he said.

Related posts

Learners reassured on final exams

Lesotho Times

First Lady takes on HIV prevention role

Lesotho Times

26 Chinese deported

Lesotho Times