…as opposition demands cost estimates
Seithati Motšoeneng
THE National Assembly was this week divided over the proposed Lesotho University of Health Sciences Bill, 2026, with members of the opposition parties questioning the financial implications of establishing the institution and accusing the government of pushing ahead without adequately accounting for the cost to taxpayers.
The heated debate erupted after opposition legislators demanded that Mokhethoaneng Member of Parliament, Mokhothu Makhalanyane, who moved the Bill, provide cost estimates, arguing that Parliament could not responsibly consider establishing another university without knowing how much it would cost.
The Bill seeks to establish the Lesotho University of Health Sciences as an autonomous public higher education institution in accordance with the Higher Education Act, 2004. It also proposes repealing the National Health Training College Act, 1992.
Among other functions, the proposed university would offer courses in health-related fields as determined by its council. It would also promote research, innovation and the advancement of knowledge, particularly in addressing health, socio-economic and technological challenges.
The institution would further be expected to promote academic scholarship and foster relationships between health professionals in Lesotho and their counterparts in other countries through collaboration and institutional partnerships.
Background
Lesotho does not have its own medical school. The Bill follows the government plans announced in March, when then Health Minister Selibe Mochoboroane told Parliament during the presentation of his ministry’s proposed M2.6 billion budget for the 2026/27 financial year that the Family Medicine School in Hlotse, Leribe, would be upgraded into a fully-fledged national medical school.
The school, which opened in 2023, is expected to operate with support from the Lesotho-Boston Health Alliance (LeBoHA) through clinical training sites, including Motebang Hospital, Queen ‘Mamohato Memorial Hospital (QMMH) and the National Health Training Centre (NHTC) in Maseru.
Mr Mochoboroane said the first intake of Bachelor of Medicine and Bachelor of Surgery (MBChB) students was expected in July 2027.
The NHTC would be transferred to the Ministry of Education and Training to give it the autonomy required for accreditation by the Council on Higher Education.
Mr Mochoboroane said the plans had been delayed for years by resource constraints but that “under the current budget, we now have the resources to establish a medical school”.
Mr Makhalanyane, who chairs Parliament’s Social Cluster Committee, had earlier told the Lesotho Times that the Committee had worked on developing the NHTC and that a Bill would be tabled to elevate it into a university of health sciences.
The Bill
Motivating the Bill, Mr Makhalanyane argued that the university was essential to addressing the shortage of medical professionals and reducing Lesotho’s costly dependence on foreign healthcare facilities.
He cited the 97,000 referrals received by QMMH alone as evidence of the pressure on the country’s healthcare system.
“Lesotho is at a point where Queen ‘Mamohato received 97,000 referrals, so this university will help in having more doctors and the relevant workforce we need to build our health system,” he said.
He said the government made approximately 7,000 referrals to South Africa last year, costing the state about M330 million annually.
“Last year, the government of Lesotho did 7,000 referrals to Bloemfontein, whereby a person costs the country M2,290 a night aside from medical bills,” he said.
“That amount is estimated at around M330 million per year that the government of Lesotho has to take out every year.”
He further revealed that approximately 4,000 Basotho awaiting heart operations in South Africa had been told they would have to wait until July 2028 because of limited capacity.
“The government of South Africa is saying these people will wait until July 2028 to enter, because we don’t have any more space,” he said.
Mr Makhalanyane said the referral crisis was the result of years without the capacity to train the specialist medical personnel needed locally. Patients requiring surgery, cancer treatment and specialist care consequently had to be sent across the border.
He also disclosed that the government had considered sending some patients on the referral waiting list to Botswana as an alternative to ease the backlog.
Opposition pushback
However, Advocate Lekhetho Rakuoane (Proportional Representation) questioned whether Lesotho could afford another university when existing institutions were struggling financially.
He said Botswana had a much larger budget and greater financial resources, arguing that Lesotho should first strengthen its finances before establishing additional institutions.
“Botswana’s budget is about P100 billion. We want universities that are like those in Botswana without increasing the budget. There is an English saying that goes, ‘who is fooling who’. We can’t do things with emotions and seeking status without first weighing our financial muscle. Let’s increase financial muscle first, then increase the universities.
“We fail to make Lerotholi Polytechnic a university … Yes, we love medical issues, but why are we developing silos? The government must answer that question.
“Why can’t we strengthen the universities that we already have, so that they can develop other universities? Why can’t the National University of Lesotho (NUL) make other universities and others like medical schools?” he asked.
Adv Rakuoane also questioned the Bill’s compliance with Standing Order 53 (4), which requires cost estimates to accompany legislation involving public expenditure.
He read the provision, which states: “In the case of a bill involving the expenditure of public money an indication of the cost shall be annexed to the bill. The annexure shall be provided (a) by the Minister of Finance in case of a government Bill.”
He warned that the government’s numerical strength in Parliament did not entitle it to disregard parliamentary procedures.
“Are we saying just because the government has numbers, we should skip this standing order … yet you can’t produce money? You are unable to help Lerotholi Polytechnic and NUL. Students have not been given sponsorship. It is an embarrassment.
“We cannot afford pride. Yes, we know the government wants to have a university, and we want to be sure that it is made a genuine thing. We want to strengthen the universities of this country, not establish universities for political point-scoring at the cost of taxpayers. What are we going to do when it fails?” he asked.
Points of order
Democratic Congress’s Rethabile Letlailana also challenged the Bill’s compliance with the Standing Orders, arguing that Parliament should not debate legislation that did not meet its procedural requirements.
“This thing is out of order. Why are we even debating this issue when it does not align with the standing orders? Should we not discuss something that complies with the standing orders of this House?” he said.
Mr Makhalanyane responded that the Bill could not be passed without the cost estimates.
“We cannot pass the bill without filling in the cost estimates,” he said.
Mr Letlailana again rose on a point of order, prompting Deputy Speaker, Tšepang Tšita-Mosena, to ask whether he was raising a point of order on another point of order.
The exchange became personal when Mr Makhalanyane told him to sit down.
“Who is Letlailana?” Mr Letlailana retorted. “Pastor, sit down; you are out of order,” he added, referring to Mr Makhalanyane’s pastoral calling.
Mr Letlailana insisted that MPs needed to understand the financial implications before considering the Bill.
“Is the House being asked to discuss this and pass it in darkness? We would be doing what we don’t know.
“If Mr Makhalanyane has knowledge of the figures, why can’t he share them, because Parliament is this House, not him? Why does he believe that he is the one who is supposed to know the figures of this thing and tell us to sit down?” he asked.
Motion to adjourn
Adv Rakuoane subsequently invoked Standing Order 41 to move that the debate be adjourned, allowing MPs time to study the cost estimates document, which they had received only during the proceedings.
“I am moving for Standing Order 41 so that we go and look at the cost estimates. The government is unable to pay scholarships right now. They can’t add more universities without agreeing,” he said.
Standing Order 41 allows a member who has risen to speak on a question before the House to move, without notice, that the debate be adjourned.
Ms Tšita-Mosena put the motion to the House. Although opposition MPs supported the adjournment, the government benches called for a division.
Of the 56 MPs who voted, 35 opposed the adjournment while 21 supported it. The motion was defeated, allowing debate on the proposed university to continue.
