Lesotho Times
[adrotate banner="13"]
Crime & CourtsNews

‘Our sister’s life was not worth M15 000’

…as Seitlheko family accuses Adv Thaba of misleading court

…and failing to prosecute murder case

Moorosi Tsiane

THE Seitlheko family has been left heartbroken and outraged after the man who killed their sister, Mpoeakae Seitlheko (‘Malimpho Moletsane), was fined a mere M15 000 for culpable homicide instead of facing a murder conviction.

The family, which had hoped to see justice served for their sister, who was killed by her husband, former Lesotho Mounted Police Service (LMPS) officer Lebohang Moletsane, on 19 February 2021, has blamed Crown Counsel Advocate Steve Thaba for what it describes as a disappointing handling of the case.

They accused Adv Thaba of misleading the High Court, keeping them in the dark about developments in the matter and appearing to side with the defence instead of vigorously prosecuting the case.

Their anger follows Monday’s ruling by High Court Judge Mafelile Ralebese, who found Moletsane guilty of culpable homicide after he pleaded guilty to the lesser charge, despite initially facing a murder charge.

The family questioned how the prosecution could accept the reduced plea when, according to the evidence outlined in court, Moletsane had allegedly pursued their sister, forcibly taken her away and stabbed her to death.

In outlining the case, Adv Thaba told the court that had Moletsane pleaded not guilty, the Crown would have called several witnesses to testify about the circumstances surrounding ‘Malimpho’s death.

The first witness was expected to be Teboho Lebusa, who was in Mohale’s Hoek on the day of the incident, assisting ‘Malimpho with funeral preparations.

“He would tell the court that it was late in the evening when they were sitting inside the deceased’s car that Moletsane arrived and violently dragged ‘Malimpho out of her vehicle, demanding that she get into his vehicle. This witness would tell the court that as he tried to intervene, Moletsane slapped him and he let them go,” Adv Thaba told the court.

The second witness was expected to be ‘Masenate Mofoka, whom Moletsane allegedly contacted through a video call.

According to Adv Thaba, Moletsane told Ms Mofoka that he intended to kill himself because he had already killed ‘Malimpho. He also allegedly showed her the deceased’s body inside his vehicle.

The third Crown witness was to be Lehlohonolo Lesole, who received a telephone call from Moletsane at around 22:00 on the same evening.

Moletsane allegedly told Mr Lesole that he was at Lepereng and needed his assistance.

When Lesole arrived, he found that Moletsane’s vehicle had crashed. Moletsane had sustained minor injuries, while ‘Malimpho was already dead, with a wound on her back.

Lesole and the person accompanying him rushed Moletsane to hospital and alerted the police about the accident.

The Crown was also prepared to call two police officers, including the identifying officer and the arresting officer.

Adv Thaba further indicated that the prosecution would have submitted a pathologist’s report showing that ‘Malimpho died from traumatic internal bleeding caused by a stab wound.

Another piece of evidence was Moletsane’s confession before a magistrate, in which he admitted stabbing his wife.

According to the confession, the couple was travelling from Mohale’s Hoek to Maseru when they approached a speed hump near Maseru. Malimpho allegedly opened the vehicle door and attempted to escape.

Moletsane said he stopped the vehicle and chased after her before stabbing her in the back with a knife.

They subsequently returned to the vehicle and, while driving, he threw the knife out of the window.

After considering the facts presented by the prosecution, Justice Ralebese found Moletsane guilty of culpable homicide.

During the sentencing proceedings, Adv Khosi Lesuthu made submissions in mitigation on behalf of Moletsane, while Adv Thaba addressed the court for the Crown.

The court heard that the couple had separated and were no longer living together. Moletsane suspected that ‘Malimpho was involved in an extramarital affair.

He also wanted her to withdraw a protection order that prohibited him from coming within 100 metres of her.

In delivering her judgment, Justice Ralebese said the evidence showed that ‘Malimpho had been alive and well before she was stabbed but died shortly afterwards. The post-mortem report established that her death resulted from a stab wound inflicted with a sharp object.

“The accused, as a reasonable man, ought to have foreseen that stabbing the deceased would lead to her death. With that foresight, he, however, proceeded and stabbed the deceased, and the court finds him guilty of culpable homicide,” Justice Ralebese ruled.

Turning to sentencing, the judge said the court was required to consider three factors: the nature of the offence, the interests of society and the personal circumstances of the accused.

She said sentencing served several purposes, including deterring the offender and others from committing similar crimes, rehabilitation, retribution and preventing further offences.

Justice Ralebese noted that gender-based violence was rife in Lesotho, particularly among couples, where husbands often brutally took the lives of their wives.

She said the sentence should therefore serve as a deterrent and demonstrate that violence was not an acceptable way of resolving personal differences.

“A sentence should be an indication that violence cannot be used as a means to resolve social differences,” she said.

The judge said the court had also considered the two children who had been left without their mother at a tender age. She further acknowledged the pain suffered by the deceased’s family following her death.

She noted that Moletsane had been a police officer at the time of the offence and was expected to uphold the law, yet had resorted to violence to resolve his personal differences.

Justice Ralebese said ‘Malimpho had already left Moletsane when the offence occurred and that, even if he believed she had left him for another man, he had other options, including seeking a divorce, rather than taking her life.

The judge also considered the children’s welfare, observing that losing both parents could have a devastating impact on their upbringing.

She further took into account Moletsane’s guilty plea, which she said demonstrated remorse and a willingness to accept responsibility for his actions.

Having considered all the circumstances, Justice Ralebese sentenced Moletsane to a fine of M15 000 or 10 years’ imprisonment in default of payment.

The sentence, however, did little to appease the deceased’s family, who said they were deeply disappointed by both the outcome and the manner in which the prosecution had handled the case.

Speaking to the Lesotho Times shortly after the ruling, family members, who requested anonymity for fear that Moletsane might also kill them, accused Adv Thaba of failing to keep them informed about developments in the case and misleading the court by suggesting that he had consulted them and secured their agreement.

“We are not happy at all with this decision. Does the court believe our sister’s life was worth only M15 000? The deceased was our sister, Mpoeakae Seitlheko, and Advocate Thaba is not telling the court the truth when he claims that he discussed these issues with us as the family of the deceased. He has always kept us in the dark,” one family member said.

The family also disputed the court’s understanding of the children’s living arrangements, saying they were not under Moletsane’s care, as had been suggested.

They said the children, aged 18 and 16, were living with their maternal grandmother at Tšenola, while Moletsane stayed with his mother at Ha Thamae.

According to the family, Malimpho had been a nurse and the children were surviving on money she had left behind. They accused their father of failing to provide for them.

The family further questioned why the prosecution had accepted the culpable homicide plea when, in their view, the circumstances pointed to a deliberate killing.

They said the couple had separated after Moletsane allegedly subjected their sister to abuse and repeatedly pursued her, prompting her to obtain a protection order barring him from coming within 100 metres of her.

“Our sister had obtained a protection order against Moletsane because he kept following her. The court had ordered that he must never come within 100 metres of her. He came to our home during the funeral, dragged her into his car and drove away with her, only to kill her. And the Crown calls that culpable homicide?” they asked.

The family also rejected suggestions that Malimpho had left Moletsane for another man, insisting that she had walked away from the marriage because of his alleged abusive behaviour.

They alleged that Moletsane had previously burnt household property at the home they shared in Mohale’s Hoek.

“This man had always been violent towards our sister. He is lying when he says she left him for another man. The reason she left was because the accused was abusing her. He even burnt her household property when they were staying together in Mohale’s Hoek.

“He killed her deliberately because he had been following her. We are not happy at all, and we believe justice was not done for our sister simply because the prosecution decided to act as defence lawyers instead of prosecuting its case,” the family said.

Related posts

Govt in belated moves to reverse seizures of assets

Lesotho Times

New exam for drivers

Lesotho Times

Mosisili clashes with minister

Lesotho Times